What Will It Cost to Heat This Home?
The heating system is one of the biggest hidden costs in a home, and it never shows up in the listing photos. Two houses at the same price can differ by $1,000 or more every winter depending on the fuel they burn. Here is what the average household is expected to spend this winter (November through March) by main heating fuel, from the U.S. Energy Information Administration’s Winter Fuels Outlook released October 6, 2026.
| Heating fuel | Avg. cost this winter | Rough monthly avg. | Vs. last winter |
|---|---|---|---|
| Natural gas | $640 | about $128 | Down 9% |
| Electricity (heat pump or baseboard) | $1,196 | about $239 | Up 4% |
| Propane | $1,246 | about $249 | Down 3% |
| Heating oil | $2,115 | about $423 | Up 21% |
January is the peak month for every fuel, so the biggest bill of the year usually lands right after the holidays. These are national averages, and a Lancaster County home’s real bill depends on its size, insulation, and the age of the system, but the ranking holds up locally: gas is the cheapest way to heat here, and oil is the most expensive this winter by a wide margin.
What to check before you fall in love with a house
- Fuel type and system age. Ask what heats the home and how old the furnace, boiler, or heat pump is. A newer heat pump or gas furnace costs far less to run than an aging oil boiler.
- Ask for 12 months of utility bills. Sellers can provide them, and real bills beat national averages every time. I ask for these on every home my buyers seriously consider.
- Oil and propane tanks. Check the tank’s age and condition, and whether a propane tank is owned or leased. A leased tank can lock you into one supplier’s prices.
- Gas availability. Some Lancaster County streets have UGI gas lines and some do not. If a home has oil heat but gas is on the street, a future conversion is a real option worth pricing out.
- Budget the January bill, not the average. If the winter budget only works in a mild month, it will hurt in the coldest one.
What about solar panels?
Plenty of Lancaster County homes now come with solar panels, and they can be a real plus or a real headache depending on one question: are they owned or leased?
- Owned panels are the good version. They cut the electric bill directly, which matters most in a home with a heat pump or electric heat, where solar can take a real bite out of that $1,196 average winter. Through PPL’s net metering, extra power the panels send to the grid earns credits against the power the home pulls at night and in winter.
- Leased panels or a power purchase agreement need a hard look. The lease payment rides along on top of your electric bill, the agreement usually has to transfer to you at closing (and the solar company may check your credit), and it can add paperwork and time to the sale. Get the full agreement and the transfer terms before you write an offer, not after.
- Ask for the production history and a year of electric bills. Real output numbers show what the system actually saves in this house, through a Pennsylvania winter, not what a brochure promised in July.
- Check the roof underneath. Panels on a roof that needs replacing in five years means paying to remove and reinstall them when the roof is done. Panel age, inverter age, and remaining warranties all belong on your question list.
- Pennsylvania solar credits are modest. PA has a solar credit market, but credit values here are low compared to states like New Jersey, so do not let anyone sell you the panels as a big income stream. The value is in the lower electric bill.
Touring homes and want the heating numbers run on one before you write an offer? Call or text me at (717) 406-7337.
Source: U.S. Energy Information Administration, Winter Fuels Outlook, October 6, 2026. Figures are average U.S. household spending on the home’s main heating fuel, November through March, and include other uses of that fuel such as water heating and cooking. Monthly averages are the winter total divided by five months.